Thread:CureHibiki/@comment-386913-20171124112329/@comment-25034020-20190423034419

I took a while to respond cause gosh, reading your thoughts had me kinda annoyed.

For one, Star Twinkle shares the same writer as Maho Girls. And two, same character designer as the one who designed Suite and Dokidoki. So that might explain your discomfort with the season and that is one thing that doesn't bother me about your response. Because I respect if you don't like those two seasons.

But it was the Sailor Moon comparison that got to me. As someone who adores Sailor Moon a lot, I do not see any simlarities with these two shows. The only similarity is space and I don't know why that is such a stupidly huge flaw. Sailor Moon doesn't own space and I wish I could tell that to every magical girl fan out there.

Star Twinkle takes a more fictional approach and has space adventures in a completely made up more colorful crazy appearing space. And the planets they go to aren't your average Mars, Pluto, Neptune etc. It's made up planets that have appearances that don't even match the laws of physics. Sailor Moon for one, doesn't even go to space that often. The only planet, which isn't even a planet, that they go to that isn't Earth, is the moon. Which, like I said, isn't a planet to begin with. And in Stars, I suppose they went to space (can't remember), but one thing for sure, it wasn't a space adventure and it wasn't as feel good as Star Twinkle is taking it.

But what you mentioned about the slice of life aspect for Star Twinkle, it's still there. Yes, the girls may go on adventures, but we still get to the see their mundane side, see them grow and live most their life as teenagers. It's only been 12 episodes but I think Star Twinkle is doing a great job at balancing its lore and the slice of life aspect. Better than Sailor Moon if I had to compare. But that's not fair cause I'm juding 12 episodes against a 200 episodes series.

Anyway, I'm sorry if I completely misinterpreted what you said but after sitting on your message for a month, I couldn't really read it any other way >.<